top of page
  • Writer's picturealbumwords200

111) Goodbye Mr MacKenzie - Good Deeds and Dirty Rags

Regular readers (I know, let me pretend I have regular readers) will remember in the Love & Money review I mentioned going to the Queen Margaret Union in the 80’s.

Glasgow was on the up, with the already mentioned Love and Money, Hipsway, Fruits of Passion, and Blue Nile all regularly played and all seemingly on the verge of a breakthrough.

For me, the best of the lot was Goodbye Mr Mackenzie featuring Big John from The Exploited on guitar and future Garbage lead singer Shirley Manson on keyboards and backing vocals. I attended several of their concerts and they were as good live as on record.

This record is ten perfect songs all building to magical choruses and the harmonising between lead singer Martin Metcalf, Shirley Manson and Rhona Scobie works perfectly and needs to be heard none more so than on the rousing openers Open Your Arms and Wake It Up.

Goodwill City is built on a single riff before the band all come in and

Candlestick Park is more laid back but beautifully layered and emotional.

Lead single, The Rattler had top ten hit written all over it but only scrapped into the UK top forty, still to this day when the organ starts its instantly recognisable and I would call it a classic Scottish single, one of our best.

The song Goodbye Mr Mackenzie is excellent driving along on a catchy chorus, should have been another hit.

Dust builds and builds and when Manson comes in with the line “Over the railroad track” she enriches the song, destined for bigger things.

The album ends with Good Deeds all rhythmic drums and Metcalfe’s vocals becoming more deranged. What an album.

Garbage had their moment in the sun, it’s an injustice Goodbye Mr MacKenzie didn’t.


GIVE IT A STREAM: sadly, the album is not available, listen on YouTube, buy it on vinyl or CD and if you can catch them now, they have reformed I would strongly recommend it. The Rattler is available on streaming sites.

202 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

205) The Church - Starfish

People at work tell me that most of the bands I am into they have never heard of, and I think but how can you have not heard of them. Then I started to write reviews and asked people to make suggestio

204) The Ramones

I went on holiday in April and was with my much better half in a very trendy designer clothes shop purchasing t shirts so my stunning physique could be covered at the pool. You probably won’t know thi

203) The The - Dusk

God’s sake he had kept us waiting four years for this one he surely wouldn’t go that long again, would he? The same line up from Mind Bomb were still with us so a certain Johnny Marr is present for on


bottom of page